How controversial pesticide research all but vanished from a major conference

The Nugget

  • Corporate influence from agrochemical companies like Corteva and Bayer led to the almost non-existent presentation of neonicotinoid research, a crucial topic in entomology, at the 2023 Entomological Society of America conference.

Make it stick

  • 🐝 Neonicotinoids Research: Vital research on neonicotinoids impacts bee health.
  • 🏛️ Influential Corporate Partners: Companies like Corteva and Bayer hold significant power in shaping conference content.

Key insights

Controversy Over Neonicotinoids at ESA Conference

  • Entomological Society of America's corporate partnership program, with significant contributions from agrochemical companies like Corteva and Bayer, led to a lack of focus on neonicotinoid research at the 2023 conference.
  • The disappearance of scholarly research on neonicotinoids, despite their controversial impact on bee populations, raised concerns among scientists.

Influence of Corporate Sponsors

  • Corporate sponsorship, including exclusive partnerships and additional fees for special events, plays a substantial role in shaping conference content and priorities.
  • Corporate employees hold positions on the ESA's governing board and serve as editors for prestigious scientific journals.

Shift in Research Focus

  • The scientific community's focus on multiple stressors impacting bee colonies has shifted the emphasis from individual factors like neonicotinoids to a more holistic approach.
  • Lack of neonicotinoid research from seasoned scholars at the conference suggests a change in the field's research priorities towards broader ecological factors.

Industry Presence and Student Participation

  • Industry presence, particularly from agrochemical companies, serves as a pipeline for students to enter corporate careers in entomology.
  • The ESA meeting provides networking opportunities for students and industry representatives, potentially influencing career choices and research directions.

Global Perspective on Neonicotinoid Research

  • While neonicotinoid research faced minimal representation at the 2023 ESA conference, global interest and funding for studies related to neonicotinoids have been steadily increasing.
  • Research shows a significant rise in publications and funding dedicated to neonicotinoid studies, indicating a heightened focus on ecological impacts and international research collaborations.

Key quotes

  • "It’s hard. People wanted to make me look bad." - Emily May, Xerces Society conservation biologist, on facing technical questions and intimidation from agrochemical industry attendees at the ESA conference.
  • "For a lot of us bee scientists, we already have a verdict. They’re doing harm." - S. Hollis Woodard, UC Riverside professor, highlighting the consensus among researchers regarding the harmful effects of neonicotinoids.
  • "Without pesticides, you’re not going to eat anything. Without pesticides, you can’t live." - Vera Krischik, University of Minnesota associate professor, emphasizing the essential role of pesticides in food production while advocating for a ban on neonicotinoids.
This summary contains AI-generated information and may have important inaccuracies or omissions.