Skull and Bones - Review

The Nugget

  • Skull and Bones by Ubisoft is a game that falls short compared to Assassin's Creed Black Flag in many aspects, priced at $70 with in-game spending and a season pass, declared as a quadruple A game by the CEO, despite being a disappointment when compared to its predecessor.

Key quotes

  • "It is no exaggeration to say that every core element of this game Black Flag did it better right down to the sailing and the ship combat."
  • "To Ubisoft's credit there isn't any other game quite like this one. This is a really accessible low stakes arcade Pirate game that you can play solo."
  • "Skull and Bones was fine, but the context matters. The $70 price tag, in-game spending, and the CEO declaring it a quadruple A game all contribute to its disappointment."

Key insights

Skull and Bones as a Game

  • Skull and Bones is Ubisoft's attempt at a pirate-themed game that lacks depth and innovation compared to its predecessor, Assassin's Creed Black Flag.
  • The game features accessible sailing and combat mechanics but fails to deliver a compelling narrative or immersive experience expected from a AAA title.
  • The core gameplay mechanics are functional and accessible, making it easy to pick up and play but fall short in providing a satisfying and immersive experience compared to Black Flag.

Context Matters

  • The context surrounding Skull and Bones, like its high price, in-game spending, and the CEO's claims, contributes significantly to its perception as a disappointment.
  • Despite being playable and offering some enjoyment, the game's failure to live up to expectations is amplified by the broader context, including comparisons to Black Flag and industry standards.

Gameplay Mechanics

  • The sailing and combat mechanics in Skull and Bones are lacking in depth and immersion compared to Assassin's Creed Black Flag.
  • Combat is accessible and functional, focusing on arcade-style gameplay with an emphasis on customization through various weapon types and strategies.
  • The game design favors accessibility and simplicity, making it easy for players to engage with but ultimately lacking the depth and excitement of its predecessor.

Make it stick

  • 💰 Even though Skull and Bones is playable, its high price, in-game spending, and unmet expectations highlight the importance of context in evaluating a game's success.
  • 🏴‍☠️ The game's accessible arcade-style gameplay may be appealing to some players looking for a casual pirate experience without the complexity of more immersive titles.
  • 🌊 While Skull and Bones offers playable mechanics, comparisons to Assassin's Creed Black Flag reveal its shortcomings in providing a compelling and immersive pirate adventure.
  • 🎮 Players seeking a simple and straightforward pirate game may find some enjoyment in Skull and Bones, but it falls short in delivering a truly immersive and engaging experience.
This summary contains AI-generated information and may have important inaccuracies or omissions.