Why Does Acting Feel So Different Now?

The Nugget

  • Acting has evolved from a theatrical, typecast approach to a nuanced exploration of psychological realism and emotional truth, marking a significant transformation in performance standards over the last century. This shift reflects broader changes in film and audience expectations.

Make it stick

  • 🎭 Early film acting was characterized by clear, exaggerated delivery, focusing on dialog enunciation rather than emotional depth.
  • 🌟 Marlon Brando's performances in "A Streetcar Named Desire" and "On the Waterfront" epitomized the shift towards naturalism and emotional authenticity in acting.
  • 📜 Method acting, popularized by actors like Robert De Niro and Daniel Day-Lewis, emphasizes immersive preparation, often blurring lines between character and actor.
  • 🎬 The techniques associated with Stanislavski's teachings, like affective memory and psychological realism, have significantly shaped modern acting but don't encompass all effective methods.

Key insights

Historical Context of Acting

  1. Early Hollywood performances prioritized dialogue clarity and star types over emotional authenticity.
  2. By the 1950s, pivotal performances (e.g., Brando) began influencing a shift towards psychological realism.
  3. John Garfield's subtle performance in the early 1930s highlighted a movement from representational to presentational acting.

The Birth of Method Acting

  1. Method acting grew out of teachings from Lee Strasberg and Stella Adler, emphasizing immersion into character to elicit natural emotions.
  2. Robert De Niro took this approach to extremes, driving a taxi for "Taxi Driver" and embodying characters intensely, setting the trend for intensive character immersion.
  3. Criticism of method acting centers on its potential for psychological harm and disruptive behavior on set, creating a backlash against the approach.

Evolution and Impact

  1. Stanislavski's impact shifted acting towards authenticity and believability, evolving the art from theatrical presentation to deeper emotional connections.
  2. The blending of various acting techniques (Stanislavski, Strasberg, Adler) allowed for diversity in achieving realism within performances.
  3. Recent shifts in film production methods further advanced this transformation, as filming techniques became more conducive to capturing realistic performances.

Key quotes

  • "When everything on stage is a lie... what kind of truth is that?"
  • "Acting is an art, not a science."
  • "To this day, there are many who would consider this the wrong way to perform Shakespeare."
  • "If the audience thinks you're acting, you failed them."
  • "Our aim is not only to create the life of a human spirit, but also to express it in a beautiful artistic form."
This summary contains AI-generated information and may have important inaccuracies or omissions.