Are Cannabis Edibles Safer Than Smoking? - The New York Times

One-liner

Cannabis edibles offer a smoke-free alternative but come with their own set of complications, such as unpredictable potency and delayed effects, which may not necessarily make them safer than smoking.

Key insights

Understanding the Appeal and Risks of Edibles

Edibles are gaining popularity as a perceived healthier alternative to smoking cannabis, aimed at avoiding the respiratory risks associated with smoke inhalation. Cannabis-infused products, like chocolate fountains at weddings or gummies, are marketed for their convenience and discretion. However, the delayed and often unpredictable onset of effects posed by edibles' digestion process complicates dosing, potentially leading to uncomfortable or hazardous overconsumption.

The Dose Dilemma

The main challenge with edibles is their dosing complexity. Unlike smoking, where the effects are almost immediate, the effects of edibles can take anywhere from 30 minutes to several hours to manifest. This variability, influenced by factors such as stomach contents and individual metabolism, can lead to the consumption of higher doses than intended, resulting in incidents of paranoia, delusions, and emergency room visits, as highlighted by Dr. Collin Reiff.

The Respiratory Risks of Smoking

Smoking cannabis is not without its dangers, chiefly respiratory issues resulting from inhaling smoke containing toxic compounds similar to those found in tobacco. While vaping appears to offer a safer alternative by eliminating certain harmful compounds, it introduces other risks through potential irritants and contaminants.

The Shared Hazards

Regardless of the consumption method, cannabis use carries risks including increased heart rate, potential for heart failure, and impaired cognitive functions affecting memory and concentration. These dangers underscore the importance of considering dose and frequency in cannabis consumption.

Key quotes

  1. "Edibles allow you to enjoy cannabis without the negative side effects of smoking."
  2. "You can’t black and white say edibles are safer than smoking, or smoking is worse than vaping — there are different risks for the different routes."
  3. "I see far more adverse outcomes in people who use edibles."
  4. "Cannabis smoke contains many of the same toxic chemicals and carcinogens as cigarette smoke."
  5. "With cannabis, and for really anything else, dose and frequency really drive health risks."

Make it stick

  1. The Delay Dilemma: Edibles' effects can take hours to kick in, leading to a dosing dilemma that can end abruptly in the ER.
  2. Smoke vs. Edible: While smoke harms the lungs, edibles skirt respiratory risks but introduce unpredictable highs and stronger cognitive impacts.
  3. The Core Cannabis Caution: No matter the method—edible, smoke, or vape—the guiding principle for safety is mindful moderation in dosage and frequency.
This summary contains AI-generated information and may have important inaccuracies or omissions.